STACEY (TANTRUM) — CREATIVE-DIRECTION DOSSIER

Stacey Smith · Tantrum Agency · Aspen Dental creative lead Compiled 2026-08-14 · Juliet-cited (every item = her exact words or the exact spec + real source)

---

0. WHO / SCOPE / AUTHORITY / COVERAGE

Who: Stacey Smith, creative lead at Tantrum Agency — Aspen Dental's creative/visual agency (imagery + color + concept; the "Ask Aspen" campaign platform). Email s_smith@tantrumagency.com; colleague Dave Tann d_tann@tantrumagency.com (recipient-only in this inbox — zero emails FROM him exist). Board files were physically authored by Allison Peden (deck) and Josh Vick (territories) at Tantrum; Stacey is the sharing/direction lead — all shares came from s_smith@tantrumagency.com.

Source: memory reference-tantrum-aspen-creative-direction.md; Gmail thread 19ffb6a240d9a744 "Today's AD meeeting"; Package Report author fields per TANTRUM-READOUT.md provenance.

Scope: ASPEN ONLY. Tantrum has no ClearChoice engagement — do NOT attribute any CC direction to her. Erin Karr 8/12: "how do we get a Stacy for ClearChoice??"

Source: memory reference-tantrum-aspen-creative-direction.md ("Tantrum is Aspen only").

AUTHORITY — "STACEY = RAFEH" (Chris ruling 8/13): her delivered creative (the 3 boards + assets) is the authoritative Aspen visual foundation, co-equal with Rafeh's direction. Authority order per /tmp/aspen-nextlevel/DESIGN-BRIEF.md:6: "Rafeh > Chris rulings ('STACEY = RAFEH', 8/13) > Nathan 8/13 docx … > Eric 8/12 Figma > Tantrum/Stacey ('not direction, just suggestions') > current site." THE ONE CAVEAT: her 8/13 23:23Z "Web thoughts" email opens "THIS IS NOT DIRECTION, JUST SUGGESTIONS/THOUGHTS" (Gmail thread 19ffd701a8bf74d2). Everything sourced to that thread is suggestion-tier, not direction — she herself defers two items (two-font family; corner radii) to "RM" = Rafeh Masood. Keep DIRECTION (boards/assets) vs SUGGESTION (Web thoughts) distinct at all times. CONCEPT vs VISUAL: Rafeh REJECTED the "Ask Aspen" CONCEPT/copy on Teams 8/13 20:19 ([Rafeh internal feedback — held]); the Tantrum VISUAL look-and-feel (palette, Figtree/Besley, chip/tile/A-super-graphic devices, photography) is KEPT and applied to the Warby page structure + Nathan's content spine.

Source: memory reference-tantrum-aspen-creative-direction.md §RAFEH REJECTED; project-aspen-warby-treatment-2026-08-13.md.

Channels swept: Gmail (4 threads, 100% of messages read: 19ffd701a8bf74d2, 19ffb6a240d9a744 all 9 msgs, 19ffb3412c6a34c0 both msgs, 19ffcdaa55a1f6f6 all 3 msgs) · her 3 Dropbox deliveries decoded locally (~/tag-docs/aspen-warby/tantrum/) · Google Drive (VERIFIED-EMPTY: zero files owned by s_smith — she delivers via Dropbox only) · calls (GAP: no local transcript of the 8/13 2-hr copy/hierarchy session; ~/tag-docs/calls/full/ ends 20260810-1700) · Figma: she is NOT a Figma commenter — no comments from her in any swept Figma file; her Figma access is UI-invite-pending (Commenter, free seat) on 0cKmL0B6ZtjcOddlEnvFYH. Disambiguation honored: Stacey Chamberlain / stacey.roberts@aprio.com (Aprio SALT tax) is a DIFFERENT person — all @aprio.com/tax/audit content excluded. Timeline note: no Stacey/Tantrum email exists before 2026-08-13 in this inbox; her promised copy pass ("Copy suggestions coming in the am") had NOT arrived as of the 8/14 sweep.

---

1. DO's — HER CREATIVE DIRECTION (authoritative, from the delivered boards)

1a. Palette

#	Value	Role	Source (Juliet)
1	#0F1F35 dark navy	"Not Sure What You Really Need?" panel bg	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Color palette — deck is RGB/sRGB → EXACT, sampled from _renders/deck-1.png flat panels
2	#1743D7 vivid blue	"Ask Aspen What Your Options Are." panel + filled chips	same
3	#88BED9 powder blue	"Ask First. Decide Confidently." panel	same
4	#9ECCE5 hero powder	hero ground	same
5	#8CC3E1 light-blue headline	headline color	same
6	#ECECE0 cream	"Ask Aspen What You Need." panel + cream chips	same

Territory palette (⚠ CMYK SWOP→sRGB APPROXIMATIONS, not authored values): navy #162B54 · dusty pink/mauve #D0A6B5 · royal #3561AD · deep royal #203D73 · sky/ice #C8E8FA · ghost-A mid blue #6890C7 · cream #F3F1EA · white #FFFFFF.

"Before locking tokens from the two territories, get authored CMYK/brand values from Tantrum" — TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Color palette + §Application guidance. No spot colors ("Spot Color Objects:" empty in all 3 Package Reports).

Palette discipline (her boards' rule): "navy + one accent per territory (pink OR blue family) + cream/white. Never all accents at once." — TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #8.

1b. Typography

Principle	Spec	Source (Juliet)
Figtree = brand workhorse	packaged Figtree-Bold.ttf; Adobe-Fonts SemiBold/Bold/ExtraBold/ExtraBold-Italic (this-means); Regular/Italic/Medium-Italic/SemiBold-Italic (yes)	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Typography (Package Reports); deck-native/Aspen_Brainstorm-AP-1_Package Report.txt
Besley Medium SERIF for editorial body	deck-native/Fonts/Besley-Medium.ttf	same
MyriadPro-Regular = utility only	packaged	same
Headline style rule	"all-lowercase, oversized, the key word set in italic ('means…', 'yes to…'), tight leading, sentence-period endings" — visible across both territories	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Typography
Weight/leading/spacing refinement (SUGGESTION-tier, adopted into build spec)	H1 weight down (Figtree Regular/Light-leaning), leading up, +10% hero-stack spacing, body −1 step — from her words "Perhaps there is a thinner version of the font? … increasing the space a bit between the header, body copy and pills (like 10%)?? … decrease the font size of the body copy; it might feel more elegant."	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2 "Web thoughts"; adopted at DESIGN-BRIEF.md:20/:70

1c. Concept & layout devices (her board devices)

Device	Verbatim / spec	Source (Juliet)
Cropped-A super-graphic	"The Aspen 'A' as a cropped super-graphic: one flat brand color (dusty pink or blue), scaled past the canvas so only strokes/counters show, layered at tile edges or behind subjects" — proven in Redscout barber frame PH_AD_Redscout_Day#4_20250921_Barbar Shop_0584.jpg pink-A composite. Converges with RAFEH's own email device ("anytime we have an Aspen dentist or clinician show up, we could use the A right behind them", thread 19ffb3412c6a34c0) — her boards prove it; Stacey's on-record endorsement of Rafeh's version: "Makes sense. Thanks Rafeh:)" (msg 19ffb6bde68d3b8b)	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #4
Tile-grid composition	"alternating flat-color copy tiles and photo tiles; AspenDental lockup small in a corner of most tiles (navy on light, white/pink on dark)"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #6
Lowercase-italic photo overlays	"Giant lowercase italic word overlays directly on photos in one accent color (pink on photos in 'this means'; light blue/navy in 'yes')"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #5
Pill/chip UI language	"fully-rounded pills for services ('Ask Aspen' chips) and affirmations ('yes to…' stack) — alternating filled/outlined, icon + label"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #7
Service chip-cloud spec	Dentures, Tooth Extractions, X-Rays, Dental Crowns, Custom Tooth Shades, Dental Bridges, Veneers, Root Canals, Custom Dentures, Dental Implants, Surgery — "rounded-full pills alternating vivid-blue fill/white text and cream fill/navy text, each with a line-icon" (⚠ see her own DON'T on jargon, §3)	deck Aspen_Brainstorm-AP-1_Package.ai "Not Sure What You Really Need?" module (_renders/deck-1.png)

1d. Photography

Principle	Verbatim	Source (Juliet)
Real candid joy	"Real, candid joy — not stock-dental posing. Mid-laugh, eyes closed, heads back, friends piled together; clinical shots only as 'collaboration' moments (mirror, X-ray walkthrough, model in hand)"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #1
Full-color natural, no filters	"Full-color natural photography. No duotones, no color washes, no gradients — color comes from the flat tiles around the photos, not filters on them."	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #2
Extreme smile crops	"Extreme smile crops as hero graphics: mouth/teeth cropped past frame edges, heart-hands framing" (yes territory: 2319fd2c…jpg 1964x1500 heart-hands smile crop)	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #3 + yes/Links inventory
Aspen's OWN Redscout shoot, not stock	"Uses Aspen's own Redscout brand shoot (real, not stock): PH_AD_Redscout_Day_3_20250920_Office_Exam Room_0804.jpg (2500x1667), PH_AD_Redscout_Day_4_20250921_Barbar Shop_0584.jpg; plus Aspen-Smile-1.jpg (2090x2772) + Aspen-Smile-1-nobg.png transparent cutout"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Asset inventory
Demo age: older-skewing subjects	"A bit young, not the right demo?" (SUGGESTION-tier origin, adopted into build spec: "Older-skewing subject per Stacey" DESIGN-BRIEF.md:69)	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2 "Web thoughts"
Photos integrated, not floated	"It also feels like an afterthought, as if it were just placed on the page. I'd remove the white border." → hero photo full-bleed/tile-integrated, edge-anchored, no floated card (SUGGESTION-tier origin, adopted DESIGN-BRIEF.md:26)	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2 "Web thoughts"

1e. Copy / voice (from her boards — note concept-status)

Item	Verbatim	Source (Juliet)
Board voice	all-lowercase affirmation lines with sentence-period endings: "this means showing up fully." / "yes. a healthier future begins here." / "yes to… asking every question. / talking about cost. / starting again / clear options"	_renders/thismeans.txt + _renders/yes.txt
"Ask Aspen" concept copy — ⚠ REJECTED as concept by Rafeh 8/13, HISTORICAL only	"Don't Just Take A Seat. Take Part." / "Ask First. Decide Confidently." / "Ask Aspen What You Need." / … "At AspenDental, patients aren't passive participants. We listen to your concerns, talk through your options, and help you play an active role in your oral care." CTA "Ask Aspen Today"	_renders/deck.txt (from Aspen_Brainstorm-AP-1_Package.ai); rejection per memory reference-tantrum-aspen-creative-direction.md
Her am copy pass	"Copy suggestions coming in the am." — NOT YET RECEIVED as of 8/14 sweep (freshest from:s_smith = 8/13 23:23Z). Watch inbox.	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2

---

2. DON'Ts — ANTI-PATTERNS SHE FLAGGED

#	Don't	Verbatim	Source (Juliet)	Tier
1	White border on hero photo / floated-card photo placement	"It also feels like an afterthought, as if it were just placed on the page. I'd remove the white border."	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2 "Web thoughts"	suggestion (adopted)
2	Too-young hero demo	"A bit young, not the right demo? And a little dark."	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2	suggestion (adopted)
3	Heavy header / cramped leading	"The header appears just a bit heavy and needs a bit more space in the leading."	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2	suggestion (adopted)
4	Simultaneous light-blue + cobalt overload	"struggling with the light blue and cobalt… Maybe lighten the cream color too" → reduce simultaneous sky/cobalt use	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2	suggestion
5	Dental-jargon pills	"They are all specific/dental jargon. Like, if my tooth hurts IDK what avenue to choose...Tooth Extractions?? maybe there is a 'general dentistry' pill"	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2	suggestion (adopted: symptom-first relabel + General dentistry pill, DESIGN-BRIEF.md:137)
6	Misaligned block	"Ask Aspen What You Need is shifted way to the left. I'm thinking it's unintentionally out of place." (fix .ask block, index.html:67)	Gmail 19ffd701a8bf74d2	suggestion (adopted)
7	All accents at once	"Palette discipline: navy + one accent per territory (pink OR blue family) + cream/white. Never all accents at once."	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #8	DIRECTION (board-derived)
8	Duotones / washes / gradients on photos	"No duotones, no color washes, no gradients"	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Image-treatment rules #2	DIRECTION (board-derived)
9	Replicating source-copy typos	"Source-copy typos to NOT carry into the build: 'i reconginze myself again.', 'saying your're nervous', 'enjoying the moment .' (space before period)" (+ "yes. is care at your peace" — peace vs pace flagged intent-to-confirm in TANTRUM-CONCEPTS-BRIEF)	TANTRUM-READOUT.md §Provenance notes	BB provenance note
10	⚠ SECONDHAND (design-brief distillation, not her words): reducing the page to one blue on white	"A page that is only one blue on white has lost the treatment" — but vivid blue #1743D7 appears ONLY on primary CTAs/links	DESIGN-BRIEF.md:22 + FUSED-TREATMENT.md §1 Rules	distillation of her boards + STACEY=RAFEH resolution

---

3. THE 3 CONCEPT DECKS

3.1 "Ask Aspen" (deck — Aspen_Brainstorm-AP-1_Package.ai, 49.3MB, RGB 1920x1080, project AD_007 Brand Concepting, authored Allison Peden)

Patient-empowerment platform: "Don't Just Take A Seat. Take Part." — patients as active participants. Homepage mock with headline panels ("Ask First. Decide Confidently." / "Ask Aspen What You Need." / "Not Sure What You Really Need?"), an 11-service rounded-pill chip-cloud on dark navy, laughing older-woman portrait on painterly blue with 4-point star, X-ray-walkthrough collaboration photos, CTA "Ask Aspen Today", circumflex-A "Âspen" lockup. Exact sRGB palette (#0F1F35/#1743D7/#88BED9/#9ECCE5/#8CC3E1/#ECECE0). Maps onto our build: ⚠ CONCEPT/COPY REJECTED by Rafeh 8/13 ("value and convenience […]") — but the palette (the only EXACT hex source), the chip-cloud device, panel rhythm, and photography direction are KEPT. The Ask-Aspen voice survives only as the /ask-aspen secondary page + "Not sure where to start?" link, never the homepage lead.

Sources: _renders/deck-1.png + _renders/deck.txt; TANTRUM-READOUT.md §1; memory rejection record.

3.2 "this means…" (territory — this means.ai, 65.5MB, CMYK SWOP 1920x900, authored Josh Vick)

Giant lowercase italic "means…" overlaid on candid photos: "this means showing up fully." / "this means not holding back." / "this means enjoying the moment ."; dusty-pink #D0A6B5 accent on navy #162B54; Aspen "A" cropped huge as flat graphic (pink on navy, pink behind subjects — the Redscout barber-frame composite); real Redscout shoot photography. Maps onto our build: the cropped-A-behind-subject hero device, lowercase-italic overlay type treatment, dusty pink as editorial (never-CTA) accent, tile-grid mosaics.

Sources: _renders/thismeans-1.png + _renders/thismeans.txt; TANTRUM-READOUT.md §2.

3.3 "yes." (territory — yes brand.ai, 31.8MB, CMYK SWOP 1920x900, authored Josh Vick)

Giant lowercase "yes. / yes to…" affirmations: "yes. a healthier future begins here." / "yes to… asking every question. / talking about cost. / starting again / clear options"; navy + blues + cream; navy pill-chip stack; ghost "A" letterform cropped even larger as tile background; extreme smile crops (heart-hands frame). Maps onto our build: the affirmation pill-stack pattern, ghost-A tile backgrounds, extreme-smile-crop photo tiles, blues+cream palette lane.

Sources: _renders/yes-1.png + _renders/yes.txt; TANTRUM-READOUT.md §3.

⚠ "this means" vs "yes" are two ALTERNATE positive territories, NOT a do/don't pair (corrected assumption — TANTRUM-READOUT.md §What was actually shared).

---

4. SUGGESTIONS — NOT DIRECTION (her 8/13 "Web thoughts" email, verbatim)

All from Gmail thread 19ffd701a8bf74d2, s_smith@tantrumagency.com, 2026-08-13T23:23:19Z. She opens: "THIS IS NOT DIRECTION, JUST SUGGESTIONS/THOUGHTS… Overall messaging, can't really speak to yet, but design I can."

#	Her words (verbatim)	Kind
1	"The header appears just a bit heavy and needs a bit more space in the leading. Perhaps there is a thinner version of the font?"	type
2	"I'd also try increasing the space a bit between the header, body copy and pills (like 10%)??"	spacing
3	"I'd also decrease the font size of the body copy; it might feel more elegant."	type
4	"I know we discussed using two font families, so I am cool with that, but I'm unsure about RM's thoughts."	question → PENDING RM (Rafeh) stamp
5	"Image does not feel right to me. A bit young, not the right demo? And a little dark. Good capture of the emotion. It also feels like an afterthought, as if it were just placed on the page. I'd remove the white border."	photography
6	"Overall, the rounded edges are larger than in the concept. It seems like you guys are embracing this, does this detail have a stamp of approval from RM? Again, some of the stuff you guys are doing can influence ours."	question → PENDING RM stamp
7	"As of now I am struggling with the light blue and cobalt, but I don't have any suggestions on how to fix. Maybe lighten the cream color too?"	palette
8	"I also struggle with the "What I really need...? section. They are all specific/dental jargon. Like, if my tooth hurts IDK what avenue to choose...Tooth Extractions?? maybe there is a "general dentistry" pill or something else."	content
9	"Ask Aspen What You Need is shifted way to the left. I'm thinking it's unintentionally out of place."	layout
10	"Copy suggestions coming in the am." — OPEN, not received as of 8/14 sweep	pending

Related open items (other threads, same tier): "I will set up a weekly TB… Should I include Erin Karr?" (thread 19ffb6a240d9a744 — unanswered, Chris's call; the weekly "Tantrum x AD Web TB" invite landed, Weds 12:30–1:15 ET, thread 19ffc34d027a0d70, first 8/19) · her ack of Nathan's homepage-hierarchy attachment: "Awesome, thank you. We will take a look. Stay tuned." (msg 19ffd4e197fb7018, thread 19ffcdaa55a1f6f6). Per DESIGN-BRIEF.md:57 the build proceeds with the two-font + 16px-radius spec, both marked "pending RM."

---

5. DOCS SHE DELIVERED

Title	Locator	Date
"Ask Aspen" concept board (deck native)	[local file] (49.3MB) + Package Report.txt · render [local file] · copy _renders/deck.txt · PDF [local file]	2026-08-13
"this means…" brand territory	[local file] means.ai (65.5MB) + Report.txt · render _renders/thismeans-1.png · copy _renders/thismeans.txt · PDF ~/Documents/TAG/tantrum-2026-08-13/this-means.pdf	2026-08-13
"yes." brand territory	[local file] brand.ai (31.8MB) + Report.txt · render _renders/yes-1.png · copy _renders/yes.txt · PDF ~/Documents/TAG/tantrum-2026-08-13/yes-brand.pdf	2026-08-13
Dropbox share email "Today's AD meeeting" (3 folders; zips retained)	Gmail thread 19ffb6a240d9a744; zips [local file]; links: [private Tantrum Dropbox link — held; request from BB] (folders) · …/yriqf00ppupvjgxjbt6d1/AE3qSIoeLRlUssXzws8Us8Y?rlkey=[withheld]&st=8lp4hmcw&dl=0 (this means) · …/jbwm067a09p34liz9hsg2/AGw1giRlkK1-IuUmqb8yRX4?rlkey=[withheld]&st=rk0ry5ke&dl=0 (yes)	2026-08-13
"Web thoughts" feedback email (NOT DIRECTION)	Gmail thread 19ffd701a8bf74d2, 23:23Z; verbatim captured in /tmp/aspen-nextlevel/design-docs.md (S4 rows)	2026-08-13
Redscout brand-shoot photography (in territory Links/)	[local file] Room_0804.jpg + PH_AD_Redscout_Day_4_20250921_Barbar Shop_0584.jpg (2500x1667); hero …/tantrum/folders/Links/Aspen-Smile-1-nobg.png (2090×2772)	2026-08-13
Weekly "Tantrum x AD Web TB" invite (Weds 12:30–1:15pm ET)	Gmail thread 19ffc34d027a0d70	2026-08-13
Her "Owning the A" ack (Rafeh direction thread)	Gmail msg 19ffb6bde68d3b8b in thread 19ffb3412c6a34c0	2026-08-13

BB-authored derivatives (context, not hers): TANTRUM-READOUT.md [local file] · TANTRUM-CONCEPTS-BRIEF.md [local file] · FUSED-TREATMENT.md + TREATMENT-SPEC.md [local file] · proof renders [local file] · memory reference-tantrum-aspen-creative-direction.md + project-aspen-warby-treatment-2026-08-13.md. GAP note: the deck she references as "Deck (sent yesterday)" has NO link in this inbox (likely sent 8/12 to chris.mason@teamtag.com) — the native files above ARE the content. She + Dave Tann are NOT on the demo-host gate roster (copy-review-brief-2026-08-13.md:33); access decision pending.

---

6. APPENDIX — FUSED PALETTE + TYPE SPEC (verbatim from [local file])

§1 Palette (FULL Tantrum palette; never reduce to one blue)

Role	Hex	Usage
Navy deep	#0F1F35	Primary text on cream/white, darkest grounds
Navy territory	#162B54	Section grounds, dark tiles
Vivid blue (owned CTA blue)	#1743D7	CTAs, links, the ONE action color
Royal	#3561AD	Secondary blue accents, chips, icon strokes
Powder	#88BED9	Soft tile fills, secondary bands
Sky	#C8E8FA	Lightest blue washes, chip fills
Dusty pink	#D0A6B5	The "this-means" accent; editorial highlights, select tiles
Cream	#ECECE0	Primary warm ground
Cream light	#F3F1EA	Alternate warm ground
White	#FFFFFF	Cards on cream, reversed text on navy

Rules (verbatim):

• "Text on cream/white is navy #0F1F35 (not black, not #032654 body text)."
• "Use navy + pink + cream + blues together per Stacey's boards. A page that is only one blue on white has lost the treatment."
• "Vivid blue #1743D7 is reserved for action (buttons, links). Pink #D0A6B5 is editorial accent, never a CTA."
• "Do not eyedrop #032654 into the UI palette; UI navy stays #0F1F35 / #162B54." (the wordmark SVG ships with #032654 baked in — keep the asset untouched)

§3 Type (verbatim)

• "Figtree (Google font; already the Aspen app face): Display: Figtree ExtraBold, lowercase, with the KEY phrase in Figtree ExtraBold Italic (the overlay device). Rows / labels / chips: Figtree SemiBold. Body / UI copy: Figtree Medium."
• "Long-form paragraph and quote body: Besley Medium (serif). … If Besley is unavailable in the target file, fall back to Figtree Medium and NOTE the substitution … do not substitute a different serif silently."

§2 Modules (Stacey's board devices, verbatim list)

1. Tile-grid · 2. Ask-Aspen chip-cloud · 3. Extreme-smile-crop photo tiles · 4. Lowercase-italic overlays (KEY word in ExtraBold Italic) · 5. Cropped-A behind subjects ("scaled way up, cropped by the frame edge, sitting BEHIND a cutout subject (clinician or patient), tone-on-tone").

---

Nothing invented. Suggestion-tier items are labeled; board-derived rules are marked DIRECTION; secondhand distillations (DESIGN-BRIEF/FUSED) are flagged as such. Aprio "Stacey" fully excluded.